Ten years have passed since Dan broke Sabrina’s heart and crushed her faith in men. Now he wants her back, but how will he get her to see beyond his old playboy persona to appreciate the man he’s become? After a serious injury, professional baseball player, Dan McMullen, requests that Sabrina Kelly, a physical therapist specializing in sports medicine take charge of his therapy. Considering their history, Sabrina is hesitant to take the assignment, but decides to do so to further her career. Day after day, Dan tries to convince Sabrina he’s not the same jerk he used to be, but Sabrina can’t forget how he’d hurt her in the past. Just when she thinks he might have changed, something happens to confirm her negative image of him. Eventually Sabrina gives in to his charm and they begin a physical relationship, but she guards the heart Dan had broken so many years ago. Before they have a chance at a real relationship, Sabrina must stop living in the past and judge Dan by his actions of today, not those of yesterday.

Megan Donnelly is not pleased when she visits a fortuneteller while on vacation and is told she will soon meet her soul mate. While any other woman would be thrilled to hear this news, Megan cannot let go of the college sweetheart who left her at the altar. Hot and hunky Chip Nealon wasn't looking for love when he decided to attend his cousin's birthday party, but the bright and beautiful Megan has him changing his mind. His grandmother always told him he would know when he met the "one." Can Chip convince Megan to take a chance on him and look to the future instead of living in the past?